Perhaps few people have been so convinced of the greatness of humanity (and the absence of God) as the twentieth century anarchist Emma Goldman. In her fiery speeches and voluminous literary output, Goldman encouraged the formation of numerous movements to set workers and, in truth, all humanity free. To set it free from its oppressive bosses, free from its restrictive governments, free from its social conventions and, most importantly, free from religion.
Writing in The Philosophy of Atheism, which she published in 1916, Ms. Goldman remarked that, "Atheism in its negation of gods is at the same time the strongest affirmation of man, and through man, the eternal yea to life, purpose, and beauty," and that, "Under the lash of the Theistic idea, this earth has served no other purpose than as a temporary station to test man's capacity for immolation to the will of God."
On the one hand, it's not difficult to disagree with Goldman. Wrongly interpreted, religion does tend to reduce our existence on this earth to a way station, a stepping stone to something which, absent a direct vision or attestation, cannot be fully proven. In addition, religion, as it has sometimes been interpreted, tends to denigrate the human being, claiming that humans are little more than the spittle of the divine. Also, needless to say, religion has, alas, been responsible for countless pain and wars throughout history.
On the other hand, rightly interpreted, religion has brought immense joy and happiness and meaning to millions, perhaps billions of human beings. It has also provided many answers to ultimate questions. Religion has brought hope. While this of course doesn't make religion true, it certainly proves its worth in the human experience. Religion is not wholly without merit.
Goldman asserts that atheism is the eternal yea to life, purpose, and beauty. Countless adherents of religion would assert this about religion, too. But we can't have it both ways. If humanity is solely material, how can it have eternal longings?
It's hard to escape eternity.
No comments:
Post a Comment